Compare how Willy Russell Essay

Published: 2020-04-22 08:25:56
1585 words
6 pages
printer Print
essay essay

Category: Brothers

Type of paper: Essay

This essay has been submitted by a student. This is not an example of the work written by our professional essay writers.

Hey! We can write a custom essay for you.

All possible types of assignments. Written by academics

The audience will be in contradiction of Mrs. Lyons because of her cunning manner towards Mrs. Johnstone. In this scene we see Willy Russell showing Mrs. Lyons to be very sly along with manipulative and Mrs. Johnstone on the other hand to be very naive. Another way Willy Russell portrays the two mothers to be different in the scene is the different language they use which suggests something about their education. On the one hand there is Mrs.

Lyons who uses mature and high-level English. On the stage we can hear the accents which remind us of the conflict between the classes. Mrs. Lyons is well-spoken, traditional of the middle and higher classes- suggesting a good education and elocution classes. Yet on the other hand, there is Mrs. Johnstone who uses a more clumsy style and misses out letters as shown in the play, Effin and blindin. She uses a Liverpudlian accent on stage, suggesting the lack of a proper education and implying a connotation of commonness. This could also suggest that in a way Mrs. Johnstone has a narcissistic view of the world.

Hence this is another way Willy Russell is portraying the two different mothers in Blood Brothers which may have an effect towards the audience. Furthermore, Willy Russell also portrays the two mothers differently when Mrs. Lyons decides to fire Mrs. Johnstone. In this scene the audience will have deep sympathy towards Mrs. Johnstone. This scene is after Mrs. Johnstone gives birth to the twins. We see Mrs. Johnstone very caring towards her baby whereas Mrs. Lyons at first treats her baby like a product or bargain. The audiences will now feel concerned towards Mrs. Johnstone and may take Mrs.

Lyons to be insensitive. Nonetheless in this scene, Mrs. Johnstone continues to work for Mrs. Lyons, however eventually Mrs. Lyons feels she no longer wants Mrs. Johnstone around who decided she will take the baby with her despite having sworn on the bible. In order to stop her Mrs. Lyons tells Mrs. Johnstone of a superstition that if twins separated at birth learn that they were once one of a pair they will both immediately die. Mrs. Johnstone feels she cannot take the baby as she does not want to be a murderer and leaves. Here Willy Russell shows that Mrs. Johnstone is very caring whereas Mrs.

Lyons is extremely conniving and manipulative by going against her word along with using superstitions to defend herself. The audience will now be repulsed by Mrs. Lyons. Willy Russell than moves the story on seven years as we see Mickey and Edward becoming Blood Brothers. From the start, on stage we see several indications of the class separation that cannot be made apparent in the text. For example, the use of costume immediately causes us to make an assumption about each mother. Mrs. Lyons dresses Eddie with his clothes neatly pressed whereas Mrs. Johnstone dresses Mickey as if he has just been dragged out of a hedge backwards.

Here we see another way Willy Russell is comparing both mothers in Blood Brothers. Furthermore, as the play moves on, the audience will be affected in the scene where Mrs. Lyons is convincing Mr. Lyons to move. In this particular scene, Willy Russell is portraying her to be a liar and pretender as she persuades her husband to relocate by pretending to be ill. Mrs. Lyons becomes so worried about the fact that Edward is mixing with Mickey that she decides to move house. We can see that Willy Russell is clearly showing that Mrs. Lyons is a fraud seeing that he has portrayed her to lie on several occasions.

He also contrasts the two mothers by showing Mrs. Johnstone who perhaps does not really care if Mickey mixes with Edward yet there is Mrs. Lyons who is desperate to be transferred somewhere else. Furthermore, Mrs. Johnstone becomes aware of Edward moving and gives him a locket with a picture of herself and Mickey. At this point in the scene, the audience will feel sympathetic towards Mrs. Johnstone because we see her helpless as her child is being separated from her. The audience will think Mrs. Lyons to be a cruel mother because she is not taking into account her sons relationship with his best friend, Mickey.

At this point the song Oh Bright New Day is sung and during this song Mrs. Johnstone and her family move into their new house as the Act comes to a closing stage. Moreover, another important scene in the play is when Mrs. Lyons appears in Mrs. Johnstones kitchen as she accuses her of following them and quarrels over the locket she gave to Edward. We see Mrs. Lyons trying to manipulate Mrs. Johnstone by bribing her with money so that she could move away. Ill get it for you. If you move away from here. How much? This shows that Mrs. Lyons is being portrayed as a controlling person. In response Mrs. Johnstone says, Nothing!

Nothing (pause). You bought me off once before¦ This implies that Mrs. Johnstone is the type of person that learns from her mistakes. It also shows that rather than viewing Mrs. Johnstone as a cruel character, we tend to sympathize with her dilemma. We see her as down-to-earth despite being trapped by her social position and her lack of funds. We also see that she does not see money as the answer to all of her problems as we see her refuse money from the desperate Mrs. Lyons, Mrs. Lyons: Thousands¦ Im talking about thousands if you want it, and think what you could do with money like that. In reply, Mrs.

Johnstone: Id spend it. Id buy more junk and trash; thats all. I dont want your money. Ive made a life here. Its not much of one maybe, but I made it. The above scene indicates that Mrs. Lyons is very conscious of her social position and that she sees money as a solution to the problems of Mrs. Johnstone. Furthermore, in this scene Willy Russell portrays Mrs. Lyons to be a very aggressive character when she does not get her own way as she attempts to attack Mrs. Johnstone with a kitchen knife. She appears as a neurotic and obsessive character that appears to be losing control. We see a contrast between her and Mrs.

Johnstone because Mrs. Johnstone is shown to be very composed and collective. This is proven in the play where the narrator says, We see throughout the above Mrs. Lyons has opened the knife drawer and has a lethal looking kitchen knife in her hand. He then says, Mrs. Lyons lunges again but Mrs. Johnstone manages to get hold of her wrist, rendering the knife hand helplessly. This quote proves that Mrs. Johnstone is handling the situation calmly and not over reacting. This is also means that the audience will have deep empathy for Mrs. Johnstone who was just trying to make a new life for herself and her children.

The audience will detest Mrs. Lyons at that moment because of her belligerent manner. In the same scene, Mrs. Lyons is being presented as very superstitious, I curse the day I met you. You ruined me¦ Witch (Suddenly pointing). I curse you. Witch. All of this shows that Mrs. Lyons feels so threatened by Mrs. Johnstone that she has been driven to want to hurt or even kill her. We then also see quite a huge contrast in the scene where Mrs. Johnstone allows Mickey and Edward to go to the cinema to watch the Swedish Au Pairs film. Here the audience will see the difference between Mrs. Johnstone and Mrs.

Lyons. We know that Mrs. Lyons would not be as liberal. We see that Mrs. Johnstone has a better understanding and acceptance of the fact that young boys will be sexually curious and she does not try to suppress their curiosity. This means that Mrs. Johnstone has a better awareness of teenagers which earns her instant credibility with her two sons and the audience. We see her as more down-to-earth than Mrs. Lyons and the more approachable mother. This scene is also an indication that happiness during upbringing is not assured by social status or wealth. It also shows that Mrs. Johnstone and Mrs.

Lyons have a completely different view of life. In conclusion, one the one hand, sometimes Willy Russell portrays Mrs. Johnstone to be the real mother and induces the audience to be attracted to her. Russell than portrays Mrs. Lyons to be the false mother and sways the audience to find her unsympathetic and snobbish. He portrays her as a cold woman who does not show much emotion. We see her as over-protective of Eddie as she fears his bond with the Johnstone family. Yet on the other hand, Willy Russell tends to make the audience to believe that Mrs. Lyons and Mrs. Johnstone are equally sympathetic.

He portrays both mothers to be loving and caring mothers who make the best of things. In general, Willy Russell does portray Mrs. Johnstone to be the real mother seeing that she understood the tender relationship between Mickey and Edward. Willy Russell portrayed Mrs. Lyons to be a very selfish woman because of her previous actions like sending Edward to boarding school and showing Mickey that Edward and Linda have been unfaithful. The audience will also feel very understanding and sympathetic towards Mrs. Johnstone throughout the play whereas they may have felt hatred for Mrs. Lyons.

Warning! This essay is not original. Get 100% unique essay within 45 seconds!


We can write your paper just for 11.99$

i want to copy...

This essay has been submitted by a student and contain not unique content

People also read